[The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory Books ] Free Reading online as Ebook ↠ Anna Green

  • Paperback
  • 352
  • The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory
  • Anna Green
  • English
  • 27 May 2019
  • 9780814731277

Anna Green º 7 review

review The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory 107 Twentieth century Ranging from Empiricism to Postcolonialism Marxism to the Ethnohistorians each chapter begins with an introduction to the particular school the main protagonists the critics and is followed by a useful section of further readings From the classic such as G R Elton's England Under the Tudors and E P Thompson's The Making of t. A great overview of the different types of theory used in historical research If you need a basic understanding of each group to help ground the difficultphilosophical text that you are studying this book gives great insight

Free download The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and TheoryThe Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory

review The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory 107 He English Working Class to the recent such as Henrietta Whiteman's White Buffalo Woman and Judith Walkowitz's City of Dreadful Delight the diverse selections collected here bring together the leading historians and theorists of the century Comprehensive and accessible to undergraduates The Houses of History is ideally suited to classroom use. For a book so thick it has surprisingly little to say Each chapter of this book has a small introduction into a particular way of writing history followed by a long exert from a book that adheres to that style of history The examples are often far too long and the explanations far too short At times you walk away wondering if you actually gathered anything about that style of history It would be much better if the first section was rigorous

Read ë eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB º Anna Green

review The Houses of History: A Critical Reader in Twentieth-Century History and Theory 107 Every piece of historical writing has a theoretical basis on which evidence is selected filtered and understood This is as true of scientific empiricism as it is of poststructualism The Houses of History provides a comprehensive introduction to the twelve schools of thought which have had the greatest influence on the study of history in the. How To Analyze It Targeted to a course in historiography Houses of History discusses 12 different approaches to presenting and analyzing historical events My own interest in this kind of a book was sparked back in high school by The Pooh Perplex a humorous look at literary analysis styles from Marxism to literary snobbery to English Romanticism Grasping the essential patterns of a style is like mastering different techniues of dance or a craft the overview allows one to embrace and appreciate each either as a spectator or as a performerEach selection is divided into two parts The first is an overview by the authors the style is about with a few uestions at the end to stimulate discussion The second part is an example essay by a professional historian who employs that style While the first part comes with footnotes and referenced the sample essays do not which IMV is a drawbackWhile the overviews were uniformly uite good I had problems with some of the readings E P Thompson s piece Exploitation on the status of tradesmen in the English industrial revolution had some elements of the Marxism it was supposed to illustrate but seemed to owe to the unseen hand of Adam Smith Richard Wall s essay on the composition of British Households since 1650 certainly did illustrate uantitative Historical Methods but was so suitably boring in it s use of limited statistics that anyone unfamiliar with the approach would henceforth wish to ignore it Henrietta Whiteman s post colonial exposition illustrated the emic bias of the genre While directly contrasting European empiricism with indigenous narratives the latter came off as cloyingly romanticized and the choice of a self interview rather than a 3rd person exposition of multiple sources put this into a category of oral history Finally Walkowitz s Science and the Seance fits the style of a newspaper article with its meandering descriptive detail The appropriateness of the story of Mrs Weldon a Victorian era spiritualist who s estranged husband tried to commit her to a lunatic asylum would fit better into a post structural framework if she were to tie this to Michel Foucault s analysis of the label of madness as a means to control fringe members of societyOn the other hand I was blown away by Hayden White s The Fictions of Factual Representation White is someone who I ve had on my list to read for some time I found his euivalencing of historical analysis to fictional rhetoric disturbing yet seductive Braudel s essay from The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II and his concept of 3 levels of time reflected in the social influences of mountain regions was impressive Braudel is considered the founder of the Annales view of history and this is certainly an apt choice Inga Clendinnen s discussion of the disintegration of 16th century Yucatan society came in the wake of the Spanish conuest especially concerning women was fascinating showing off the Ethno Anthropologic approach admirably Erik Erikson s analysis of Hitler s appeal to the German population not as a substitute father figure but as an overgrown adolescent older brother provided an excellent appeal for a Psycho historical perspectiveThe examples of the remaining 4 chapters on Empirical Sociological the value and problems of collecting Oral Histories and the dimension of Gender in history were fair and reasonable representationsThough long past university age I found the book useful in clarifying some matters and useful in fuzzifying others Allowing for the substitution of the less recommendable readings this could be the basis of a really interesting seminar based or online course